how-sure

Five wells: which five?

English · Русский

Planning a shallow stratigraphic drilling campaign when only a few wells are allowed: which sites to drill, what their cores can date, and what the first cores change.

Where older units come up beneath the seabed, short cored holes give the first hard data on source rock, reservoir and seal in a basin with no wells, years before an exploration well. My part as the geologist: planning and supervision of the first shallow stratigraphic drilling campaign on the Russian Arctic shelf (Malyshev et al., 2023, which I co-authored): 10 wells, 300 m of core, 13 stratigraphic units; the results are published (doi:10.2113/RGG20224459). The campaign was planned for five wells and drilled ten in one season. The trade press reported the drilling as the first stratigraphic wells in the region and the northernmost on the Russian shelf (Oil & Gas Journal; see also Offshore Magazine and, in Russian, TASS), and I appeared in a Discovery Channel documentary on the Arctic drilling campaign.

This page shows, on made-up numbers, how such a campaign is reasoned when attempts are few. It opens on three findings, each closed by what the published paper reports; the form to try your own section is below them.

Open the page · download the file (one HTML file, works offline) · one page: PDF

The three findings on the made-up example: the score for each number of wells, the two ways to place a core, and the plan against the first two cores

Three findings

A. Why not stop at five: what each next well buys. In the example, five wells out of twelve candidate sites take 85 % of what all twelve could give; the fifth adds 1.2 points of 23, the sixth 0.8, the twelfth 0.1. What the extra wells buy is back-up: the source rock and one key boundary still rest on a single hole. In most drilling, fewer wells is the aim. Here it is the other way round: the product is core, and the scarce resource is the weather window and the vessel’s time, so each extra hole in the same season is another try at the targets. In the published campaign, sites were chosen as principal and reserve ones, aiming at the widest stratigraphic range with wells shallower than 100 m. One of the ten wells was a reserve site, drilled during a storm mooring; it penetrated the same Upper Devonian unit as one of the principal wells.

B. The weak link is dating, not coring. Six of seven target units are cored on average, yet fewer than three of six boundaries are dated. A boundary is dated only if the hole brings back core, the core crosses it, and the rock on both sides gives an age. A core in the middle of a unit is safe on a rough pick; a core across a boundary is worth more, but needs a sharp one. In the published campaign, ages came from conodonts, fish remains, spores and other fossils; in well SSD 23 no macrofauna was encountered and the age came from palynology. The fossil ages moved two boundaries on the seismic: the Ordovician–Silurian boundary to an unconformity earlier taken to separate Silurian and Devonian, and the Silurian–Devonian boundary to near a horizon earlier read as lying inside the Lower Devonian.

C. The first cores change the plan. Enter what a core showed. If it fits, the page narrows where that horizon can lie at the other sites and chooses the remaining wells again. In the example the fifth well changes after two cores, mainly because the first hole brought back what its back-up was planned for. If a core does not tie, the sites still to drill on that horizon are held until it is re-picked. In the published campaign, the later sites were adjusted from new seismic rather than from cores: while one vessel drilled, a second shot ultrahigh-resolution seismic across the planned sites. Within a well, total depth and coring intervals were decided from the rock description sent from the site. Overall, the first results tend to make the section older than the base model implied.

Where else this applies

The page is about shallow drilling offshore. A related question comes up elsewhere:

Using it

  1. Open the page and read the three findings on the example.
  2. Look at the checks at the bottom: ALL 49 PASS, against hand calculations and an independent count (sites_ref.py).
  3. Then enter your own section, candidate sites and error ranges under “Try your own section”.

How the page counts, the rules it uses, the example in full and the limits are in how-it-works.md. The three limits that matter most: the numbers are made up; errors are taken within the ranges you enter, so a wrong reflector shows only after drilling, as a core that does not tie; and the page cannot re-pick a horizon, which takes the seismic and the whole core description.

Files

File What it is
shallow-wells-plan.html The page: one file, no internet needed, no data leaves the browser
five-wells-one-page.pdf One page: the campaign, the three findings, the links (Russian)
how-it-works.md The count, the rules, the example in full, the checks, the limits
sites_ref.py The independent count behind the checks (Python, numpy)
screenshot-page.png The page on its example

References: Bugge, T., et al. (2002). Shallow stratigraphic drilling applied in hydrocarbon exploration of the Nordkapp Basin, Barents Sea. Marine and Petroleum Geology, 19, 13–37. Malyshev, N. A., et al. (2023). Stratigraphic drilling in the northern Kara Sea: first case and preliminary results. Russian Geology and Geophysics, 64(3), 257–269. doi:10.2113/RGG20224459

Built with AI assistance; the geology and the checks are mine.

Licence: CC BY 4.0. Maxim Balagurov, petroleum geologist · v1.2.1 · DOI 10.5281/zenodo.24242389